What CPU is it anyway?


Contents


Intro

I was browsing the Intel SDM recently and something jumped out at me.

...
15  RFLAGS.OF := if Is_Zero (result[operand_size+:operand_size]) then 0b0 else 0b1;
16  RFLAGS.SF := UNSPECIFIED : Bit;
17  RFLAGS.ZF := UNSPECIFIED : Bit;
18  RFLAGS.AF := UNSPECIFIED : Bit;
19  RFLAGS.PF := UNSPECIFIED : Bit;
20  RFLAGS.CF := if Is_Zero(result[operand_size+:operand_size]) then 0b0 else 0b1;

The flags SF, ZF, AF and PF are all "Unspecified" which got me thinking:

There are a few reasons you might want to be able to do that:

Does it work?

I fuzzed various instructions with unspecified outputs across a few different CPUs and found a few places where you can distinguish microarchitectures apart:

Here's good one for if you ever need to tell AMD and Intel apart:

int is_intel(void) {
    int tmp = 0x0800;
    asm volatile(
       "bextr %%rax, %%rax, %%rax \n\
        pushf \n\
        pop %%rax" 
    : "=a"(tmp));
    return ((tmp >> 4) & 1) == 0;
}

It turns out, for BEXTR

And if you can't remember if your CPU is AMD Zen3 vs Zen5:

int is_zen5(void) {
    int tmp = 0;
    asm volatile(
        "movb $0x7F, %%al\n\
         addb $1, %%al \n\
         bsf %%eax, %%eax\n\
         pushf \n\
         pop %%rax" 
    : "=a"(tmp));
    return ((tmp >> 11) & 1) == 0;
}

The BSF/BSR instructions:

Some other examples:

Most Intel CPUs I tested seemed to agree here, except for one. On a Hetzner VPS that claims a "Skylake Xeon":

Additional Info

Code: https://gist.github.com/CUB3D/9f887a205af58ffb1d1d032dbcddaf2d

CPUs tested: